Asphalt Shingles: Are Three-Tab Shingles or Architectural Shingles Better?

How to Choose the Right Shingle For Your Home

Before you begin exploring the shingle options for your roof it’s important to analyze both your wants and needs so you can choose the best product for your unique situation. You’ll want to carefully consider all of the following before you make a decision so you can properly evaluate all your options. 

• Budget – The top priority for the vast majority of homeowners when choosing a new roof is their budget. Before you fall in love with a product, make sure it’s within your financial reach. 
• Durability – Is the roof you’ve chosen capable of standing up to the local climate? Carefully consider your local weather patterns while you’re looking at roofing options to decide which roof will work best for you. 
• Longevity – How long is this roof going to last? Depending on needs, some homeowners are looking for a roof that will last for the life of their home while others don’t place quite so high a priority on how long the roof will last. 
• Style – Your roof makes up a big chunk of the curb appeal for your home. Choosing a roof that compliments your style is always a good idea. 
• Environmental Impact – If your carbon footprint is at the front of your mind, you’ll want to put some thought into the environmental impact of your new roof. Certain roofing materials are more recyclable than others, so it’s definitely something to consider. 

Three-Tab Asphalt Shingles

Three-tab shingles are what come to mind for most people when they think of an asphalt shingle roof. These shingles are named for their three tabs that give them the appearance of being three, uniform pieces.  

Advantages

• Three-tab shingles are lighter and have less material which makes them easy to install and transport. 
• These are the most affordable roofing material on the market. 
• Three-tab asphalt shingles are very easy to repair when needed.
• They are available in a variety of colors. 

Disadvantages

• Three-tab shingles are one of the least durable roofing systems on the market. 
• They don’t generally stand up well to high winds and hail. 
• These shingles usually have a shorter life expectancy which means shorter warranties. 
• They don’t add much value to a home. 
• They offer minimal curb appeal enhancement with their flat appearance.  

Architectural Asphalt Shingles

Architectural asphalt shingles, also called dimensional shingles, are quickly becoming more popular among many homeowners. They’re available in a variety of shapes and sizes and offer a more dimensional look than traditional three-tab shingles. 

Advantages

• Architectural shingles are much more durable than three-tab shingles. 
• Their thicker build enhances weather resistance. 
• They have a much wider variety of colors, designs, and styles. 
• Different shapes and thicknesses give them a more attractive, dimensional appearance. 
• Architectural asphalt shingles will add value to your home. 

Disadvantages

• Architectural shingles have a higher upfront cost than three-tab shingles.  
• They’re much heavier than three-tab shingles which can potentially cause problems if your home’s structure can’t handle the added weight. 
• Depending on the specific shingle chosen, they may or may not stand up to extreme weather.  

Asphalt shingle roofs are popular among Slidell homeowners for a reason – they’re affordable, durable, and stylish. If you’re ready for a new asphalt shingle roof, call Bergens Roofing today, and let us walk you through all your options to find the best roof for your home!